Select Page

Caroline Moreau

Feb 17, 2023

What role do family planning and gender equity play?

I think that the role of family planning is a non-negotiable.

For example, what helped India bring fertility down from the 1970s onward was free contraceptive access, integration of maternal and child health services, rising female literacy, all of these things worked in conjunction to support fertility decline. India's history isn't uniformly positive. The coercive sterilization campaigns during the Emergency in the mid-1970s, and the target-driven approach that continued after, show what happens when programs prioritize numbers over people. India moved to a target-free approach in the mid-1990s, after the 1994 Cairo conference, and that shift toward rights and choice is the lesson I'd emphasize.

I think the goal of any family planning program should thus be, how do you ensure that people have the availability of information and services to achieve the families they want to? I don't think it's anybody else's decision as to what that should be besides the couples.

But going further, I think gender equity goes beyond family planning.

Looking at India again, we see that urban labor force participation for women is very low: about 28% in 2023-24, compared with nearly half of rural women.  Which is a really big puzzle that I think a lot of sociologists are devoting a lot of time on because so many urban women are well educated. As I was mentioning, there was so much investment in female literacy, female education. So the education levels are not what's at issue. Turning that into work is key to the demographic dividend.

School children and infrastructure development

How can countries measure progress toward realizing a demographic dividend?

Particularly female labor force participation. I think that one's really big. I would look at the dependency ratio as well.  But what I think we don't think about as much that is very relevant to my work on India is local government, fiscal, and administrative capacity.

You need the local government fiscal and administrative capacity to be good enough to actually execute on all of the things that we say we want seen and tracked.

I think that one of the most visible  outcomes to measure is GDP per capita growth. I would also look at something like the Gini, which is a measurement of inequality in a country. Frameworks like the Population Reference Bureau’s 4 dividends – economic, health, education, governance – are a helpful reminder that the payoff from a changing age structure goes well beyond the GDP.

On the other hand, you can also have this sort of wealth creation by the few that can push a country's metrics to look a certain way, but it obscures the fact that maybe a majority of the country is not achieving that level of success.

So it’s important to remember that National averages really mask subnational stories. In India, in the essays that I've written, I basically have trifurcated the country into three groups based on their demographic transitions (The Aging Frontier, the Transitioning Middle, and the Youthful Engine), and they're vastly different.

If I were determining a policy for demographic dividend in India, I would really look at it from a state by state perspective rather than something at the national level.

Conclusion

The demographic dividend offers countries an important opportunity, but favorable population trends alone cannot guarantee economic gains. Realizing that potential requires timely investments in health, education, employment, gender equity, and effective governance.

As countries navigate increasingly diverse demographic futures, understanding where they stand in their demographic transition, and what investments are needed now, is essential.

Join Our Global Network

Subscribe to WHGI's Positive Disruptions newsletter for the latest news, opportunities, and research in sexual and reproductive health, gender equity, population dynamics, and more.

* indicates required